top of page
hand-baked in Westchester, NY

big cookies.
bigger cravings.

CosmicBrownie.png

Big, gooey cookies baked fresh and packed with flavor. From everyday cravings to special celebrations, we've got you covered,

Fetti.png
Star.png
Star.png
Vegan.png
Star.png
CookiesnCream.png
pick your favorites

on the menu

SaltedPecan.png

LIMITED EDITION SEASONAL COOKIE

salted pecan

Meet our Salted Pecan cookie - packed with dark chocolate & crunchy pecans, a touch of molasses, perfectly golden crispy edges, a soft & chewy center, and topped with flaky sea salt.

THE CLASSIC

Chocolate Chip

Vegan.png

CAMPFIRE

S'mores

Smores.png

THE VIRAL ONE

Dubai Chocolate

GermanChoc.png

BROWNIE STUFFED

Brownie Chip

BrownieStuffed.png

NUTELLA STUFFED

Nutella Chip

NutellaChip.png

NUTTY + SWEET

Choc Chip Walnut

WalnutChocChip.png

CINNAMON SUGAR

Snickerdoodle

Snickerdoodle.png

ALLERGY FRIENDLY

Vegan Chip

ChocChip.png

REESE'S PB CUP STUFFED

Reese's Chip

ReesesChip.png

FLUFF STUFFED

Fluff Chip

FluffChip.png

LIFE OF THE PARTY

Funfetti

Fetti.png

ICONIC CRUNCH

M&M

M&M.png

ALLERGY FRIENDLY

Gluten Free Chip

GlutenFree.png

OREO STUFFED

Oreo Chip

OreoStuffed.png

NUTELLA + BROWNIE

Nutella Brownie Chip

NutellaBrownie.png

CLASSIC COMBO

Cookies & Cream

CookiesnCream.png

FUDGY + NOSTALGIC

Cosmic Brownie

CosmicBrownie.png

ITALIAN COOKIE STUFFED

Rainbow Chip

RainbowChip.png

COOKIE BUTTER STUFFED

Cookie Butter Chip

CookieButterChip.png

FUDGY + DECADENT

Fudge Brownie

Brownie.png

ordering is as easy as 1, 2, 3

no long lines, promise

01

Select your flavors

Browse our cookie menu, pick your favorites, and build your perfect box!

02

Choose your date

Pick a date and choose pickup or local delivery. 

03

Check your inbox

You'll receive a confirmation and we'll follow up to finalize & for payment.

Requests only. Nothing is charged online.

custom cookie favors

make your celebration a little sweeter

Make any occasion a little sweeter with our individually packaged mini or regular-size cookies, complete with custom stickers personalized to match your event's theme, colors or message.

BIRTHDAYS

BRIDAL/BABY SHOWERS

WEDDINGS

GRADUATION

CORPORATE

Customize your design here

YOUR STICKER, YOUR WAY

COMING 2027

The BAM Cookie Cart

grab one on the go

find us at local spots

Your favorite BAM cookies, available at local cafés, restaurants and more throughout Westchester!

Smokehouse Tailgate Grill · Love You a Latte · The Sailhouse · One Rare Italian Steakhouse · TVB by: Pax Romana · Bagel Land ·

where it all began
our story

it started with late-night baking

What started as a hobby while working full-time in accounting quickly became something much bigger. With a little encouragement from my sister and countless late nights in the kitchen, Baked After Midnight was born.

bottom of page